As Ontario’s population ages, social workers and social service workers are increasingly supporting older adults. The decisions these clients make may be questioned by family members, caregivers or service providers. In these situations, practitioners may find themselves balancing concerns about safety with an older adult’s dignity, preferences and right to make their own choices.
For Joy Friesen, RSW, that balance has been a consistent theme throughout her career. Joy has worked across a range of practice settings, including mental health, crisis support, public health and palliative care. These experiences have shaped how she approaches work with older adults. One lesson has remained clear: people do not stop being the author or expert of their lives simply because they become older, develop health concerns or need more support.
Keeping the older adult client at the centre
Joy recognizes that concerns about an older adult’s well-being often come from a genuine place of care. A family member may be worried about falls. A provider may be concerned when someone refuses treatment. A care team may believe that moving someone to a more supportive environment is the safest option. Good intentions can sometimes lead to decisions being made for the person rather than with them. “Concern can easily become like control unknowingly,” Joy says.
For practitioners, this means taking time to understand the older adult’s perspective. What do they want? What do they understand about the situation? What matters most to them? Are we responding to an actual risk, or to our own discomfort with their decision?
Joy also emphasizes that safety cannot be the only measure of good care. Quality of life can include relationships, privacy, culture, purpose, independence and belonging. An older adult may place greater value on remaining at home, maintaining a familiar routine or spending time with people they care about, even when those choices involve some risk.
A meaningful approach starts with empathy and curiosity. Rather than immediately deciding that a choice is unwise, social workers and social service workers can take the time to understand why it matters to the person.
Looking beyond the word “no”
Respecting autonomy can begin with something as simple as listening. Joy recalls being in meetings where professionals, family members and caregivers discuss what an older adult needs while the person is sitting in the room. She encourages practitioners to pause those conversations and make sure the older adult is heard first. “The first person to be asked should be the older adult themselves,” says Joy.
Supporting autonomy does not mean expecting someone to make decisions without support. An older adult may need information presented in plain language, an interpreter, hearing support, written information or simply more time to process what is being discussed.
Joy also makes an important distinction between independence and autonomy. A person may rely on others for transportation, meals, bathing or medication while still making decisions about how those supports are provided. The focus should be on what the person can still direct and what supports can make those choices possible.
The same approach applies when an older adult says no. Refusing home care, treatment or another service should not automatically be labelled as resistance or non-compliance. There may be fear, discomfort, a lack of trust or a misunderstanding about what is being offered.
“Respecting our autonomy begins with being able to hear ‘no’ without immediately trying to turn it into a yes,” says Joy. Empathy means taking the time to understand what is behind the decision and what the person needs to feel heard, understood and respected.
Balancing safety and dignity
Joy does not see safety and autonomy as competing values. Instead, she encourages practitioners to ask: How can we reduce serious harm while preserving as much choice as possible?
Practitioners can start by being specific about the risk. What exactly might happen? How likely is it? How serious could the consequences be? Does the person understand the potential consequences?
If an older adult understands a risk and chooses to accept it, Joy encourages social workers and social service workers to consider how they can support that decision while making the risk more manageable. She refers to this as the “dignity of risk,” recognizing that adults of all ages make choices that involve some degree of risk.
Reflection is also important. Practitioners may genuinely want to protect someone, but care can unintentionally become control. Asking whether a response is based on the person’s experience or our own anxiety can create space for a more respectful approach.
Understanding the person behind the choice
Family involvement can add another layer of complexity. Joy draws on her Filipino background, where there can be a strong sense of responsibility toward parents and elders. Families may be deeply involved in caring for an older relative because of love, respect and a strong sense of family obligation. That care should be respected, but it should not replace the older adult’s voice. “Culture should make us curious, not presumptive,” states Joy.
Social workers and social service workers can recognize the importance of family and culture while still asking the individual what they want. The same principle applies to assumptions about aging, disability or quality of life. Living alone does not necessarily mean someone is lonely. Needing assistance does not mean someone is incapable. Dementia does not mean a person no longer has meaningful preferences.
Professional expertise provides knowledge, but it does not give practitioners ownership over another person’s life. The older adult remains a person first, not a diagnosis, a risk or a collection of needs to be managed.
Building trust through respect
For older adults who have experienced being dismissed, spoken for or excluded from decisions, trust may take time.
Joy describes trust as being built through “small, repeated experiences of respect.” Introduce yourself. Explain your role. Speak directly to the person. Ask permission before discussing sensitive information. Be transparent about confidentiality and its limits. Follow through on what you say you will do. Most importantly, make room for disagreement.
An older adult does not have to agree with a social worker or social service worker for the relationship to remain respectful. Listening to their concerns and understanding why they disagree can demonstrate that their voice continues to matter.
For Joy, the question practitioners can return to is simple: What matters most to you, and how can we help you preserve that? Asking a question like this can be a useful way to bring consent, autonomy, safety and dignity into the same conversation and reinforces the importance of seeing the older adult as the expert in their own life.
Ultimately, respecting autonomy is not about stepping back from professional responsibility or ignoring legitimate concerns about safety. It is about using that responsibility to understand the person, recognize what matters to them and find ways to support their choices wherever possible. Empathy and respect are a part of good practice and also how to create the conditions for meaningful consent, to preserve dignity and support older adults to remain active participants in their own lives. When we take the time to listen, question our assumptions and understand the person behind the decision, we can move from simply managing risk to supporting care that is safe, person-centred and grounded in the choices of the individual.
Joy Friesen, MEd, MSW, RSW, is a bilingual social worker, advocate, and PhD candidate in the School of Social Work at the University of Windsor. She currently serves as Director of Clinical Operations at the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA) Niagara Branch, where she brings a strong commitment to compassionate, trauma-informed, person-centred care and clinical leadership.
Previously serving as Director of Community Programs at Hospice Niagara, Joy brings extensive leadership and professional experience across mental health, crisis intervention, community justice, forensic settings, public health and palliative care. Her work is grounded in equity, social justice and a deep commitment to improving access to meaningful, high-quality care.
A passionate advocate for consent, autonomy and dignity, Joy is dedicated to elevating the voices and rights of equity-deserving populations. Her leadership reflects the values that first inspired her career in mental health: compassion, connection and the belief that everyone deserves to be heard, respected and supported.
The College thanks Joy for speaking with us and sharing her experiences. In appreciation, the College has made a donation to Hospice Niagara.
